PHYSICAL
THERAPY
Some beaches
need physical intervention to deal with problems, such as storm impact
or beach erosion. There are three major approaches of dealing with long-term
beach erosion--beach nourishment being the preferred treatment by most
coastal communities.
Beach erosion
is a national problem as 80 to 90 percent of sandy beaches are currently
eroding at rates of only a few inches to over 50 feet per year along the
outer coastline of Louisiana, the erosion "hot spot" of the
United States. Our knowledge of the causes and rates of erosion have greatly
improved in recent years, and it is clear that rising sea level results
in the long-term trend of landward shoreline movement. Coastal storms,
including hurricanes, nor'easters and El Nino events, cause episodic changes
in beach position and width. Oceanic beaches have a cyclic behavior--narrowing
in the winter and widening in the summer in response to changes in wave
activity. This seasonal fluctuation in beach dimensions is well understood
by people who live or regularly visit beaches. Others are astounded (and
dismayed) to find the beach in front of their home eroding severely or
even disappearing in the wintertime, especially during very stormy years.
Large coastal storms can overtop and flatten sand dunes, causing major
damage to beachfront houses and infrastructure, such as roads and utilities.
It is at this time that the public becomes aroused and calls for governmental
action are made.
Sand is
a valuable commodity and can be considered as a part of the necessary
infrastructure of coastal communities. As the beach goes, so goes the
local economy because the sandy beach is the draw for tourism. A wide
beach serves both as a storm buffer to protect shorefront properties and
also as recreational space. Long-term changes in shoreline position and
beach width have been studied for many coastal areas, which permits better
prediction of future changes. The average long-term erosion rate along
the U. S. East Coast is 2 to 3 feet per year, but some areas are stable
to slightly accretional while others are eroding at much higher rates.
The Cape Hatteras Lighthouse on the Outer Banks of North Carolina was
moved in the summer of 1999 because of a long-term trend of coastal erosion
that amounted to a loss of 1,500 feet during the last century-a very high
rate of sustained beach erosion.
Beach erosion
can occur because of simple inundation of the land, but it largely involves
the actual removal of sand from the beach to deeper water offshore or
movement alongshore into inlets, tidal shoals, and bays. The relative
rate of sea-level rise along the U. S. coasts has been approximately 1
foot in the last century with much higher rates along the Louisiana coast
because of rapid land subsidence. A unit vertical rise in sea level translates
into 150 to 200 units of horizontal retreat of sandy shorelines. While
sea level rise sets the conditions for landward displacement of the shore,
coastal storms supply the energy to do the "geologic work" by
moving the sand off and along the beach. Therefore, beaches are greatly
influenced by the frequency and magnitude of storms along a particular
shoreline. The rate of sea-level rise is expected to accelerate in the
coming decades in response to global warming, which would exacerbate existing
erosion problems.
The management
options available to control coastal erosion and protect beachfront properties
include retreat, shore hardening, and beach nourishment. Retreat from
the shore generally occurs in the aftermath of a major storm when beachfront
properties have been heavily damaged or completely destroyed and the building
lot has been greatly diminished or disappeared completely. Along the Outer
Banks of North Carolina, coastal retreat has been the principal response
to beach erosion and storm impact. Houses on the edge are often moved
landward before being destroyed by waves and surges during coastal storms.
The State of Texas has an Open Beaches Act that dictates that any house
standing on the beach, even if it survived the storm, must be moved off
the public property. Elsewhere, houses elevated on pilings that survived
the storm surge are condemned by the health department because of the
exposure of septic tanks on the beach. The retreat option is extremely
unpopular with local residents because everyone wants to live on the beach,
and the land is the generally much more valuable than the house itself.
Beachfront
homeowners faced with erosional problems and possible storm damage often
resort to shore hardening, especially bulkheads, in order to protect their
invesment where permitted by governmental agencies. Shore hardening refers
to the construction of a range of structures built to retain sand, interfere
with waves and currents in order to reduce their damaging effects, or
protect property from direct wave attack and hold back tidal waters. These
structures built of wood, stone, concrete, or steel include bulkheads,
seawalls, revetments, groins, jetties, and breakwaters (see Beach
Glossary). Bulkheads and seawalls can protect upland property from
damaging storm waves, but they do nothing to abate the erosion of the
beach fronting the structure. In fact, such hard shore-parallel structures
such as bulkheads and seawalls may accelerate beach erosion by reflecting
wave energy off the facing wall, impacting adjacent property owners as
well. Building such structures along retreating shorelines eventually
result in diminished beach width and even loss. Groins and jetties intercept
the alongshore movement of sand, building wide beaches on the updrift
side and causing accelerated erosion of downdrift beaches. These shore-perpendicular
structures do not create any new sand, but merely rearrange the sand that
is on the beach. Groins are most effective and not detrimental when built
as a cluster or "field" along a stretch of shoreline at the
terminus of the alongshore movement of sand, such as at a harbor mouth.
Offshore breakwaters have had mixed success, but there has been much less
testing of this technology along U. S. beaches.
Beach nourishment
is the process of adding new sand to the beach profile in order to restore
it to some former width. This is usually accomplished by dredge and fill
operations with sand pumped onto the beach from an offshore source, such
as sand bars or shoals. Beach nourishment is only feasible at the community
level as large sectors (e.g., miles of the shore) must be nourished to
be economical viable. In the early 1980s, Miami Beach was restored at
the cost of $65 million along this 10-mile strand of shore. While the
cost was high, South Beach was rejuvenated, and today it is the "hottest"
beach in the country; this beach nourishment project has paid for itself
many times over. Where the rate of erosion is high or there are nearby
sand sinks, beach nourishment projects have been much less successful-it
is not a panacea for all coastal communities. Beach nourishment does not
stop the erosion trend--it simply "resets the clock." But beach
fills achieve both goals of providing a wide recreational beach and reasonable
storm protection for beachfront development. Where coral reefs are present,
such as along South Florida and Hawaii, care must be taken because of
the potentially damaging impacts of both the dredging process and the
placement of sand, which can smother nearshore habitats and feeding areas
for fish and sea turtles.
A coastal
engineering project that is successful in one area may not be well suited
for another shore. Beaches are a part and parcel of the quality of life
in coastal communities, and efforts should be made to preserve these vital
resources.
|